Essay Example on Germline engineering in human embryos









Aim of the Study The primary purpose of this secondary literary analysis paper is to discover and explore the questions that need to be answered in germline engineering in human embryos the answers to which will enable readers to come up with a conclusion as to whether or not the scientific process should be allowed to continue My primary role will be evidence gathering mainly through literature reviews to encompass the legal questions that need to answered Data will be collected through a legal lens questioning whether or not the current law can be interpreted as vague enough to ensure the legality of the scientific practice or whether it could be argued that the Supreme Court has set precedent by allowing a case similar to this one that has the same or similar advantages and repercussions The aim of the following methods section is to develop a system that results in the proper legal papers being utilised in the study Research Approach This research employed a qualitative approach with some principles of a meta analysis 

The study did not aim to establish a cause and effect relationship as a quantitative analysis would provide it rather establishes direction based for policy decisions based on a synthesis of available quantitative and qualitative research Such policy decisions can be utilised by a wide variety of groups and individuals across a large spectrum of levels ranging from government executives to lawmakers Data Collection Tools and Procedures The research process will a fairly straightforward method to collect and analyze data and evidence Furthermore in order to examine the legality of the subject matter I will be using a secondary literature analysis that examines whether or not the legality could be determined based off of the vague wording of other pre existing laws or could be based off of precedent set forth by the Supreme Court In addition a meta analysis will be used in order to analyze the existing research on the subject matter thus enabling me to attain all the information required before asking the necessary questions and forming the necessary conclusions Data will primarily be collected through a variety of legal papers wherein the subject of germline engineering is prevalent Research would be attained through the gaps in the current framework of the law as well as observing whether a vast majority of law journals come to an agreement as to the legality of germline engineering

A majority of articles were gathered through a variety of academic databases including EBSCOHost Google Scholar and InfoBase Learning several online encyclopedias like Britannica as well as law reviews of reputed universities like Harvard and Columbia In order to ensure that the papers obtained are are specifically related to the topic at hand specific parameters were used to narrow the online searches For example considering that the prospect of germline engineering is a relatively recent scientific phenomenon papers written before 2010 would be basing their data off of outdated scientific proponents In addition the court case regarding the patenting of the intellectual property of the process of germline engineering is currently under review by the Supreme Court Previous attempts by biotechnological firms to place patents on the process were firmly denied Howmever recent news sees the parent founder the University of California Berkeley file an attempt for appeal with the United States Patent Trial and Appeal Board PTAB Thus papers written and published more than eight years ago would be viewed as having errored not up to date information Furthermore the papers obtained must be credible in that the author and or publishing group must not present any biases towards the topic Thus after selecting a paper based on the criterion above the author s background is researched to ensure that they have the scholarly expertise education required for the claims that they are making to be considered credible and that they are not affiliated with sponsored by or have expressed support for a group that indicated bias toward the topic

Should there be a research paper wherein the author or publishing company is found to have bias the value of the paper would dramatically reduce and would likely not be included within as evidence within the research paper Finally the papers obtained had to be substantially relevant to the research questions at hand refer to research questions subtopic In order to provide an in depth conclusion which would aptly serve and suffice the purpose of the research conducted there were four distinct subtopics that were selected based on a cursory overview of the legal topics surrounding the matter the notion of consent and testing on children the question of social imbalance the patent rights of the intellectual matter and the rights of parents Thus the papers that were chosen had to ensure that a large chunk of their paper a majority was related to at least one of the subtopics Data Analysis Within the evidence and data gathered research was gathered by creating a summary of each of the subtopics within the paper and weighing opposing viewpoints of the same subtopic against one another through a weighted value system based off of level of author and publication credibility present biases sponsors level of education etc and level of relevance to the topic a table for the list of inclusions of the paper is included in figure 1 1 Next the analysis of the research came from searching for gaps within the research present This would enable a set of previously unanswered legal questions to be written which when answered would provide policy makers with the information that they need in order to make a well informed decision on the research process

Write and Proofread Your Essay
With Noplag Writing Assistance App

Plagiarism Checker

Spell Checker

Virtual Writing Assistant

Grammar Checker

Citation Assistance

Smart Online Editor

Start Writing Now

Start Writing like a PRO